Mazur: A COLP’s Perspective
Written by Matthew Shiels, Director and regulatory and compliance specialist at Cartwright King (Manchester)
“The courts have effectively said: delegation is lawful, but only where supervision is genuine, active and defensible.”
As any COLP knows, the role keeps you busy. Compliance, training, audits, conflicts, regulatory mapping, firm wide risk assessments, AML, CPD (do we call it that anymore?), regulatory conferences, the SRA’s latest business plan, and so on. And then, on top of all of it, another shift in the decisions and guidance on the conduct of litigation.
The Court of Appeal’s recent decision in Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys LLP [2026] EWCA Civ 369 has landed. For COLPs across the profession, the judgment is not simply another appellate clarification on the Legal Services Act 2007, it is a reminder that supervision, governance and operational control within law firms of any size remain the framework holding litigation practice together.
What the Court Decided
The appeal reversed the earlier High Court position ([2025] EWHC 2341 (KB)) that had caused significant concern throughout the legal sector. The original ruling effectively suggested that many litigation tasks routinely delegated to paralegals, trainees and CILEX professionals could amount to the unlawful conduct of litigation. In practical terms, it threatened to destabilise the foundations upon which modern litigation departments are built.
Thankfully the Court of Appeal took a more pragmatic approach. It confirmed that litigation tasks can lawfully be delegated to non-authorised individuals, provided there is proper supervision, management and retained responsibility by an authorised person. The authorised solicitor remains the party “conducting” the litigation in the eyes of the law.
That said, the judgment is narrower than the relief felt across the profession might suggest. The Court did not decide that the way this particular litigation had been conducted was lawful, nor did it rule any specific working practice generally compliant or non-compliant. Whether supervision is adequate, it said, turns on the facts and degree in each case. The Law Society has indicated that the decision provides only an outline framework, and that further guidance from the SRA will follow. The practical effect is that delegation survives, but the burden of demonstrating genuine supervision now sits with the firm.
Why This Matters for COLPs
For a COLP, however, the real significance lies not in the relief felt across litigation teams, but in the operational warning signs hidden beneath the judgment. Failure rarely occurs because of a single cracked brick. It happens because of systemic weakness: poor oversight, inadequate inspections, fragmented accountability or a failure to appreciate risks. Litigation compliance is no different.
Many firms have spent years expanding litigation operations, adding case handlers, outsourcing functions, introducing volume workflows and automating processes. The Mazur litigation exposed what happens when the profession cannot clearly articulate who is supervising the structure and where responsibility ultimately sits.
The Court of Appeal may have confirmed that delegation is permissible, but it also reinforced something equally important: supervision is not decorative. It is foundational. That distinction matters enormously for COLPs.
The role of a COLP is often misunderstood internally as a reactive compliance function, a kind of regulatory inspector called in after problems appear. In reality, the role is overseeing the risk profile of a business in real time. The question is never simply whether work is being done. It is whether the systems supporting that work are capable of withstanding scrutiny when pressure is applied.
Five Areas for Renewed Focus
From a COLP perspective, the judgment should trigger renewed focus in five areas.
First, supervision frameworks must be real, not cosmetic. Firms should be able to evidence how supervisors review files, monitor decisions, escalate risk and audit delegated work.
Second, training records matter. If non-authorised staff are undertaking substantive litigation tasks, firms must be capable of demonstrating competence, escalation pathways and appropriate authority levels.
Third, governance mapping is essential. Many firms still operate with blurred reporting lines between compliance, legal management and operational delivery. Mazur demonstrates how dangerous that ambiguity can become when examined judicially.
Fourth, file audits should move beyond technical legal accuracy and examine supervision quality itself. A perfectly drafted pleading is not evidence of compliant supervision if nobody can explain who took responsibility for strategic decisions.
Finally, COLPs should revisit the cultural issue underlying the judgment: the tendency for firms to treat compliance as an obstacle to efficiency rather than the framework that permits scalable growth safely.
Not Business as Usual
The profession avoided a potentially seismic operational crisis following the Court of Appeal’s decision. Had the earlier ruling remained intact, entire litigation models, particularly in high-volume claimant work, legal expense insurance panels and consumer claims, may have required fundamental change.
To be clear, the appeal must not be viewed as permission to return to business as usual.
If anything, Mazur has handed us as COLPs a clearer mandate. The courts have effectively said: delegation is lawful, but only where supervision is genuine, active and defensible.
For me, Mazur is therefore less a victory lap and more a reminder that modern litigation practice remains a higher-risk work area and one where weak foundations rarely stay hidden.
Legal Disclaimer
All advice is correct at time of publication.
